The Glow Without the Red Flag: Navigating Self Tanning Brands and Red Dye No 40

In the quest for a sun-kissed glow without the harmful effects of UV rays, self-tanners have emerged as a go-to solution. However, navigating the world of self-tanning products can be as complex as achieving an even application.

Among the myriad ingredients to watch out for is Red Dye No. 40 - a synthetic dye found in numerous cosmetics and food products. While some swear by its ability to mimic a natural tan, others are wary of its potential health implications.

Prefer to Watch a Video?

If you don't know me, my name is Sophia and I help you find non-toxic home, beauty and personal care products. You can also find me on TikTok, Instagram and Pinterest. Make sure to subscribe to this blog to get tips on non-toxic living delivered straight to your inbox 4x / week!

Why Red Dye No. 40 Raises Eyebrows

Red Dye No. 40, also known as Allura Red AC, is a controversial ingredient. It's been linked to hyperactivity in children, allergic reactions, and even certain cancers in animal studies. Despite these concerns, it remains FDA-approved and widely used in the US. Given the debate, many conscious consumers and clean beauty aficionados are on the lookout for self-tanning options devoid of this contentious component.

Red Dye No. 40 Regulations in the EU and UK

Red Dye No. 40 is allowed in the EU and UK, but with certain restrictions and labeling requirements. In the EU, it is approved for use in food and beverages under the E number E129. However, products containing this dye must carry a warning that says, "May have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children."

This requirement is part of the EU's effort to inform consumers about potential health concerns related to certain food additives, especially concerning children's behavior and health.

The UK, following brexit, has retained much of the EU's food safety regulations, including those concerning food colorings like Red Dye No. 40. Therefore, the same restrictions and labeling requirements apply.

Despite being permitted, there's an ongoing debate and consumer concern over the use of synthetic dyes like Red Dye No. 40 due to potential health risks, including allergies and hyperactivity in some children, leading to an increased demand for products free from artificial colorants both in the EU/UK and globally.

Where Red Dye No. 40 Creeps In

Some popular self-tanning brands continue to incorporate Red Dye No. 40 into their formulas despite the harmful effects. These products often rely on the dye to achieve a certain hue or depth of color that appeals to users seeking a specific tan shade.

While these products are effective in delivering the desired bronze look, the inclusion of Red Dye No. 40 raises questions for those who are cautious about synthetic additives in their skincare and beauty regimen.

Consumers should read labels and product descriptions carefully, especially if they're sensitive to synthetic dyes or simply prefer to avoid them.

The inclusion of Red Dye No. 40 in self-tanners boils down to personal preference and individual sensitivities. For those concerned about the potential health risks associated with synthetic dyes, the good news is that the market offers a plethora of alternatives that deliver a gorgeous glow without compromising on safety or ethics.

Choosing the Right Self-Tanner for You

When selecting a self-tanner, consider the following tips to ensure you pick a product that aligns with your health, ethical standards, and desired results:

• Read the Ingredient List: Familiarize yourself with the names of synthetic dyes, including Red Dye No. 40, to spot them quickly.

• Research the Brand: Look into a brand’s ethos and commitment to natural or organic ingredients. Brands that prioritize clean beauty are less likely to use synthetic dyes.

• Patch Test: Before applying a new self-tanner all over your body, do a patch test to rule out any allergic reactions, especially if you have sensitive skin.

• Consider Your Skin Tone and Type: Choose a self-tanner that complements your natural skin tone for the most natural-looking result. Also, consider your skin type (oily, dry, combination) as different formulas cater to different needs.

• Look for Reviews and Tutorials: Seeing real results can help you gauge how a self-tanner performs without Red Dye No. 40. Online reviews and video tutorials can be invaluable in making an informed decision.

Full List of Self-Tanning Brands That Contain Red Dye No. 40

Several popular self-tan brands have been identified for containing Red Dye No. 40 in their formulas. Certain varieties of mass-market self-tanners that promise instant or very deep tans may incorporate this dye to intensify the tan color and make the product visually appealing.

After vetting and reading ingredient lists, these are the brands that I've found to contain the harmful Red Dye No. 40 in their formulations:

1. Isle of Paradise

2. St. Tropez

3. Loving Tan

4. Tanologist

5. B.tan

6. Half Caked

7. Hawaiian Tropic

8. Mine Tan

9. St. Mortiz

10. European Gold

11. Ulta Brand

12. Sephora Brand

13. Mine Tan

14. Body Drench

Here's the good news!

There are fantastic self tanners that don't use Red Dye Number 40 and prioritize clean ingredients

For those looking to steer clear of Red Dye No. 40, there's good news. The market has responded with a range of products that promise a beautiful bronze without the unwelcome addition of synthetic dyes. Here are some of my favorite options:

Here is the full list of non-toxic self tanning brands that don't make use of Red Dye Number 40 and prioritize clean ingredients:

1. Beauty by Earth

2. The Organic Pharmacy Self Tan

3. Salty Face

4. Vita Liberata Fabulous Gradual Tanning Solution

5. Sol Bar

6. Luna Bronze Solar Eclipse clear tanning mousse

7. Sephora gradual tanning drops

8. Bondi sans pure self tanning drops

9. Tropic sun drench overnight tanning mousse
   

10. Beauty pie bronze gradual tan drops

11. Eco tan invinsible tan

12. Vanilla fudge eco by sonya invisible tan
    

Let's break down some of my favorites ⬇️

1. Salty Face

Salty Face is one of my favorites, I talk about it a lot on my TikTok. This innovative self-tanner is celebrated not only for its health-conscious formula but also for its remarkable ease of application. It always gives me a seamless and streak-free tan, it doesn't stain my sheets or clothes and gives me a beautiful, natural-looking glow. Salty Face Self Tanner delivers impressive results while staying true to its non-toxic promise.

Salty Face Active Tanning Ingredient: In lieu of Red Dye No 40, Salty Face likely achieves its tanning effect through the use of Dihydroxyacetone (DHA). DHA has a rating of 3 on the EWG guidelines. DHA is a colorless sugar that interacts with the dead cells located in the stratum corneum of the epidermis, the outermost layer of the skin, causing a color change. This reaction creates the appearance of a tan without the need for sun exposure.

2. Beauty by Earth Self Tanner

Shop here

Crafted with natural and organic ingredients like organic shea butter, coconut oil, and Japanese green tea leaf extract, Beauty by Earth offers a self-tanner that’s as kind to your skin as it is to the environment. Free from harmful chemicals and yes, devoid of Red Dye No. 40, this brand champions a healthy glow.

Beauty by Earth utilizes Dihydroxyacetone (DHA) derived from sugar beets as the active ingredient in their self-tanning products to achieve the actual tanning effect.

3. The Organic Pharmacy Self Tan

Shop Here

Luxury meets natural with The Organic Pharmacy's self-tanning lotion. This product prides itself on a formula enriched with soy-derived DHA, aloe vera, and hyaluronic acid, ensuring a streak-free tan while moisturizing the skin. It's a premium choice for those avoiding synthetic dyes and seeking hydration along with color.

The Organic Pharmacy utilizes a unique 100% natural DHA derived from Sugar Beet to provide a natural-looking tan. This approach ensures that the tanning process is safe and free from harmful chemicals, aligning with the brand's ethos of using organic ingredients. In addition to DHA, their self-tan products are enriched with nourishing components like Shea Butter, known for its skin-softening properties, and Jojoba, an effective moisturizer rich in vitamins and minerals. Aloe is also featured for its calming and soothing effects on the skin

4. Vita Liberata Advanced Organics

Shop here

With a focus on purity and a philosophy rooted in skincare, Vita Liberata offers a range of tanning mousses and lotions free from parabens, perfume, alcohol, and, importantly, Red Dye No. 40. Their use of certified organic botanicals makes for a guilt-free tanning experience that nurtures the skin. Vita Liberata also relies on naturally-derived DHA to achieve a sunless tan.

5. Eco Tan Invisible Tan

Shop here

Eco-conscious and ethical, Eco Tan's Invisible Tan is the answer for those who prioritize both their health and the planet's wellbeing. Boasting a certification by the Organic Food Chain Australia, this self-tanner ensures a radiant tan without synthetic fragrances, GMOs, or Red Dye No. 40. Eco Tan Invisible Tan uses natural and organic ingredients, including a naturally-derived form of DHA, to produce a beautiful and even tan.

Wrapping It Up & Disclaimer

In a beauty industry increasingly influenced by consumer demand for transparency and safety, the presence of Red Dye No. 40 in self-tanners is a concern for many. Fortunately, the rise of clean beauty has paved the way for a variety of options that promise a golden tan without the need for synthetic dyes.

Whether you opt for a self-tanner free from Red Dye No. 40 or choose a product that includes it, the key is to make an informed decision that considers both the health of your skin and your personal beauty standards.

FTC Disclaimer: This blog post may contain affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of those product links and make a purchase, I’ll receive a commission, at no additional cost to you. This helps support the blog and allows me to continue to make content. I only recommend products that I trust, to the best of my ability and at the time of writing, to be non-toxic. This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Always read product labels and use as directed. Manufacturers reserve the right at any time to change product ingredients. Thank you for your support!

Let me know your favorite safe self tanner in the comments below. Happy (and healthy) tanning! ☀️